An investigation by The Badger Project found gaps in the state’s licensing and oversight systems, allowing some teachers accused of misconduct to return to class.
By Bethanie Gengler for THE BADGER PROJECT
A public school teacher who quit one district in Wisconsin while under investigation and was fired from another for being intoxicated on the job is now working for a third, where he taught for a year with an expired teaching license, an investigation by The Badger Project has found.
Following the termination in 2018, the Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction (DPI) revoked Rusty Shankle’s license to teach. But today, he is a junior high science teacher in the Norwalk-Ontario-Wilton School District, where licensing records show he taught for a full school year under a $56,484 contract without a valid Wisconsin teaching license. A contract he signed in May set his current salary at $60,622.
Shankle, now 52, is an example of a “wandering teacher,” educators with histories of misconduct who bounce between districts. An investigation by The Badger Project found gaps in the state of Wisconsin’s educator licensing and oversight systems that allowed some teachers accused of misconduct to return to the classroom.
Strange behavior

Shankle was a social studies teacher at Olson Middle School in Mauston from August 2006 to June 2017, where a May 2017 school district investigation found a long list of strange behavior.
The alleged incidents occurred between March 2015 and May 2017. Shankle kept a lock of a female student’s hair that had been cut at school following a lost bet, according to the investigation that The Badger Project obtained in a records request. Although Shankle claimed he threw the hair away, district officials later found it inside his desk, the investigation said.
District records note Shankle made inappropriate remarks about students’ clothing, asked students about “crushes,” and regularly pulled female students out of class to perform chores for him.
According to a summary of factual findings by the district, during a summer program, he publicly asked female students if they were on birth control. He later defended the questioning in a letter to DPI, writing that as a chaperone on camping trips, he needed to keep track of their medications.
District officials also conducted a forensic audit of Shankle’s school-issued computer, which revealed that his device had been used to visit or attempt to visit websites containing sexually explicit jokes and a site involving bestiality.
Shankle disputed the allegations in an explanation included in the investigation documents, writing that his words were taken out of context and that he either accidentally landed on the inappropriate websites or that visiting college students may have used his computer to access the explicit sites. He also said that the lock of hair found in his desk belonged to his daughter.
He did not respond to requests for comment for this story.
Before the Mauston School District could complete its formal proceedings, Shankle quit his position in June 2017, citing an “unsafe work environment” in an email accompanying his resignation letter.
State law requires school districts to report educators who resign amid suspected “immoral conduct.” On June 22, 2017, Mauston officials notified the state, prompting the DPI to open an investigation the next day.
SUPPORT OUR WORK AND HELP US INVESTIGATE THE POWERFUL!
DONATEVodka at school
Shankle, meanwhile, was looking for his next teaching job. About six weeks after leaving Mauston, he applied for a middle school social studies position at Adams-Friendship Area School District. On his application and cover letter, obtained by The Badger Project through an open records request, Shankle indicated he was “currently teaching eighth grade in the Mauston School District,” omitting that he had resigned during an active misconduct investigation.
At the time of his application, state records show the DPI had flagged his teaching license as “Under Investigation.”
DPI offered Shankle a settlement to resolve the situation: the state would close the probe with a finding of “no probable cause” if Shankle completed an online course on professional boundaries with students, according to records inspected by The Badger Project.
Shankle completed the course on Oct. 24, 2017. On Nov. 3, DPI formally closed the investigation with a “no probable cause” determination, allowing him to continue teaching.
The Adams-Friendship Area School District hired Shankle nine months later, on Aug. 22, 2018, for the start of the 2018–2019 school year. A month into his new teaching position, police were called to the district’s middle school. Staff reported Shankle was falling asleep in his classroom, and parents had reported seeing him buying vodka before school started.
According to an Adams County Sheriff’s Office report, Shankle’s preliminary breath tests administered at the school were at least 0.102%. Wisconsin’s legal limit for driving is 0.08%.
The school district fired Shankle immediately, and the DPI revoked his lifetime teaching credentials on Dec. 13, 2018, citing immoral conduct.
Even a revocation for teaching while intoxicated didn’t stop Shankle from gaining employment at a third district, where he now works. In March 2021, the DPI issued Shankle a provisional teaching license. Four months later, the Norwalk-Ontario-Wilton School District in the Driftless Area hired Shankle to teach junior high science at Brookwood School.
Teaching without a license
Chris Bucher, a DPI spokesman, said state administrative code allows the state superintendent to reinstate a teacher’s license if the educator demonstrates that the original cause for the revocation no longer exists. The applicant must also prove that their return to the classroom “will not endanger the health, welfare, safety, or education of any pupil.”
Norwalk-Ontario-Wilton Superintendent Travis Anderson said Shankle was “very forthcoming with all previous employment history” prior to being hired, stating the district was aware of his background when it determined he was an appropriate hire.
At the time, Shankle held a provisional license, expiring on June 30, 2023. He was not issued a new lifetime license until July 1, 2024. Throughout the 2023-2024 school year, Shankle taught without the required license.
Bucher said that Wisconsin statute requires school boards to ensure all professional staff are appropriately licensed. DPI has the authority to withhold state aid if a school district fails to meet certain requirements under Wisconsin law, Bucher said.
When questioned about the year Shankle taught without a license, Anderson claimed DPI confirmed Shankle was licensed “the entire time.” But an email obtained through a records request shows DPI only verified his current status.
When questioned again about the gap, Anderson acknowledged an “application submission delay” prevented the state from issuing Shankle’s lifetime license until July 1, 2024. He defended the district’s decision to keep him on staff, saying he “would not be employed if not eligible to be granted licensure.”
Reconstructing Shankle’s licensing timeline required sorting through state records marked by manual data errors, mismatched audit reports and retroactive approvals.
The DPI’s Educator License Online (ELO) database showed Shankle’s lifetime license was revoked Dec. 13, 2018, for immoral conduct, while the state’s separate License Revocations database listed two different dates for the same action. DPI said one date was a data-entry error and the other reflected Shankle’s reinstatement. After this reporter questioned the discrepancies, the state updated the dates in the database.
When the state approved Shankle’s license reinstatement in 2021, DPI’s software presented a new problem: issuing Shankle a new license would erase his 2018 revocation history from public view. To keep his past misconduct visible, Bucher said the state had to create a new, duplicate educator profile for Shankle and link it to his old one.
Although Shankle applied for reinstatement in May 2020, the DPI took 10 months to approve it before retroactively backdating his license to July 1, 2020.
While DPI licensing online records listed Shankle’s provisional credential as valid from 2020 through 2023, the DPI’s Public All Staff Report flagged him as improperly licensed for the 2022, 2023, and 2024 school years. Bucher called Shankle’s case a “unique instance” caused by the timing of annual “point-in-time” snapshot audits.
Bucher noted that Gov. Evers recently signed legislation establishing new standards for educator licensing databases and the DPI is currently updating its systems to comply. However, he said that the changes will only affect records moving forward.
Anderson, the Norwalk-Ontario-Wilton superintendent, continued to defend hiring Shankle.
When asked by email of any issues since he began teaching in the district, Anderson replied, “There have been ZERO (0) complaints, allegations, or disciplinary issues in regards to Mr. Rusty Shankle.”
This story is part of a series on wandering teachers funded by a grant from the Fund for Investigative Journalism.
The Badger Project is an independent news nonprofit in Wisconsin.
FREE TO READ. EXPENSIVE TO PRODUCE.
Creating our hard-hitting news takes a lot of time and money.
A story like this needs at least 8 hours to research, write and edit.
Please consider financially supporting The Badger Project to help us do more reporting in the future.
Until the end of the year, all donations* will be MATCHED by NewsMatch.
*Up to $1,000 per person






Leave a Reply