Moderate Democrat Ron Kind spent millions to retain the seat he’s held for 25 years, even as millions flowed in to defeat him
BY PETER CAMERON, THE BADGER PROJECT
Another election year, and another easy victory for U.S. Rep. Ron Kind, right?
Not quite. It was tight this time, as campaign cash flooded Wisconsin’s 3rd Congressional District, which hugs the Mississippi River and was won by President Donald Trump with about 52% of the vote.
Kind triumphed in the district he has held for nearly a quarter century with 51% of the vote. He received a total of nearly 200,000 votes, while Republican challenger Derrick Van Orden got nearly 190,000.
The moderate Democrat has regularly won by 10 percentage points or more, and his fundraising has always dwarfed opponents.
Until last year, when he faced his best-funded opponent ever. Kind raised and spent nearly $3 million. Van Orden: nearly $2 million.
The almost $5 million in direct donations to the candidates is the biggest load of campaign cash the 3rd Congressional District has seen in at least 20 years, according to campaign finance records. And based on trends of money in politics, probably the most ever.
“Simply put, (House Speaker) Nancy Pelosi and her allies bought Ron Kind’s congressional seat by sending him millions,” Van Orden said in an email response to The Badger Project.
Kind did not respond to multiple requests for comment.
Wisconsin’s 3rd Congressional District looks like a profile of Popeye leaning against the Mississippi and flexing a bicep that bends from La Crosse to Stevens Point more than 100 miles away.
When Wisconsin Republicans drew the districts in 2011 to their heavy favor for the coming decade, they snipped the liberal college town of Stevens Point out of the 7th Congressional District in northern Wisconsin, making that district solidly Republican, and plopped Stevens Point into the 3rd Congressional District to the west. The effect of GOP gerrymandering actually meant the 3rd was made a safer Democratic seat, said Joe Heim, a political science professor emeritus at UW-La Crosse.
Wisconsin’s 3rd is one of the few congressional districts in the country that a Democrat held but Trump won. And it was the only congressional race in Wisconsin that was close. The other seven districts were decided by 18 points or more.
Heim credited Kind’s reputation as a moderate for helping him hold the district. Kind voted against Nancy Pelosi for House Speaker in 2019, but for her in January of this year. He also had a “huge warchest” of campaign cash and “spent it liberally,” Heim added.
Van Orden was “all in with Trump, and that may have helped in some areas, but hurt in others,” Heim said, noting that Kind cruised to decisive victories in the district’s urban areas.
Van Orden kept open the possibility of running again in 2022.
“Nothing is off the table,” he wrote.
Citizens United’s effect felt
The well-known 2010 U.S. Supreme Court decision in the Citizens United case allowed for the creation of dark money Super PACs. Federal law prohibits these organizations from coordinating with political campaigns, but they can spend unlimited amounts attacking or promoting a candidate on the airwaves or in print. And they often are able to keep their donors confidential. Super PACs spent heavily in the 3rd District in the flight to flip it red.
The Congressional Leadership Fund, a Republican-aligned Super PAC, dropped more than $1.6 million to defeat Kind, according to The Center for Responsive Politics, a nonpartisan, nonprofit research group that tracks campaign finance.
Sheldon Adelson, the casino magnate and prolific Republican donor who died last month, gave tens of millions to that Super PAC.
The Democrat-aligned House Majority PAC and the American Hospital Association spent nearly $600,000 and $300,000, respectively, supporting Kind.
Much of that cash goes to purchasing TV attack ads.
Like nearly all Democrats in national politics, Kind has been supportive of more disclosure requirements in campaign finance, voting in favor of the DISCLOSE Act in 2010, which passed the Democratic-controlled House, but then was filibustered and killed by Republicans in the Senate.
Republicans have voted almost unanimously against The DISCLOSE Act, but Van Orden signaled an openness to at least some disclosure reform.
“I believe we need stronger transparency in our campaign funding,” he wrote.
Direct donations to the candidates
While Kind’s 2020 campaign haul of nearly $3 million sounds astounding, it fell far short of cracking the top 100 fundraising totals for House candidates last year.
Under federal law, the most an individual can give to a candidate is $2,800 per election. Political Action Committees can give $5,000 per election. So with a primary and a general, individuals and PACs can double that limit.
A handful of individuals gave Kind the maximum $5,600. That includes Judith Faulkner, CEO of health software behemoth Epic Systems in the Madison area, and her husband Gordon. The check was Judith Faulkner’s only donation to a politician last year. Kevin Conroy, CEO of Exact Sciences in Madison, also gave Kind the maximum $5,600.
Kind received the maximum $10,000 from the political action committees for AT&T, Boeing, Caterpillar, GE, Home Depot, Met Life, Prudential, Xcel Energy, Vanguard Group, Toyota, and many others.
Of Van Orden’s nearly $2 million in campaign donations, many individuals gave him the maximum $5,600, including the usual big spenders on the Wisconsin right: Diane Hendricks, the billionaire owner of ABC Building Supply, who lives in the Beloit area, and Dick and Liz Uihlein, owners of ULINE Shipping Supplies, who each gave the max.
The Supporting Electing American Leaders (SEAL) PAC, which backs conservative military veterans for office, gave Van Orden, himself a former Navy SEAL, the maximum $10,000. The Eye of the Tiger PAC, which supports Republican candidates and is funded by big business, gave him $7,500.
The Badger Project is a nonpartisan, citizen-supported journalism nonprofit in Wisconsin.
Lists of the top 100 donors to each candidate are below.
TOP 100 DONORS TO KIND IN 2020
|American Bankers Association||$10,000|
|AMERICAN COLLEGE OF CARDIOLOGY||$10,000|
|AMERICAN COUNCIL OF LIFE INSURERS||$10,000|
|AMERICAN FEDERATION OF TEACHERS / AFT||$10,000|
|AMERICAN HOSPITAL ASSOCIATION||$10,000|
|AMERICAN OPTOMETRIC ASSOCIATION||$10,000|
|AMERICAN PHYSICAL THERAPY ASSOCIATION||$10,000|
|AMERIPAC / THE FUND FOR A GREATER AMERICA||$10,000|
|COLLEGE OF AMERICAN PATHOLOGISTS||$10,000|
|DELOITTE TOUCHE TOHMATSU||$10,000|
|ERNST & YOUNG||$10,000|
|GENERAL ELECTRIC CO||$10,000|
|METROPOLITAN LIFE INSURANCE||$10,000|
|NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF REALTORS||$10,000|
|NATIONAL THOROUGHBRED RACING ASSOCIATION||$10,000|
|NEW YORK LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY||$10,000|
|PRINCIPAL FINANCIAL GROUP||$10,000|
|SERVICE EMPLOYEES INTERNATIONAL UNION / SEIU||$10,000|
|THRIVENT FINANCIAL FOR LUTHERANS||$10,000|
|UNITED PARCEL SERVICES / UPS||$10,000|
|WINE & SPIRITS WHOLESALERS OF AMERICA||$10,000|
|PACIFC LIFE INSURANCE||$10,000|
|AMERICAN ASSOCIATION OF ORAL & MAXILLOFACIAL SURGEONS||$10,000|
|GUARDIAN LIFE INSURANCE||$10,000|
|NATIONAL BEER WHOLESALERS ASSOCIATION||$10,000|
|NATIONAL RURAL ELECTRIC COOPERATIVE ASSOCIATION||$10,000|
|AMERICAN ASSOCIATION OF NURSE ANESTHETISTS||$10,000|
|NEW DEMOCRAT COALITION||$10,000|
|TOYOTA MOTORS NORTH AMERICA||$10,000|
|CREDIT UNION LEGISLATIVE ACTION COUNCIL / CULAC||$10,000|
|NATIONAL VENTURE CAPITAL ASSOCIATION||$10,000|
|AMERICAN ASSOCIATION OF ORTHOPAEDIC SURGEONS||$10,000|
|TEACHERS INSURANCE & ANNUITY ASSOCIATION||$10,000|
|NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF TRUCK STOP OPERATORS||$10,000|
|NATIONAL AUTOMOBILE DEALERS ASSOCIATION||$10,000|
|AMERICAN CHIROPRACTIC ASSOCIATION||$10,000|
|INVESTMENT COMPANY INSTITUTE||$10,000|
|AMERICAN COLLEGE OF RHEUMATOLOGY||$10,000|
|NATIONAL MULTIFAMILY HOUSING COUNCIL||$10,000|
|INDEPENDENT COMMUNITY BANKERS OF AMERICA||$10,000|
|AMERICAN ACADEMY OF DERMATOLOGY ASSOCIATION||$10,000|
|NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF ENROLLED AGENTS||$10,000|
|INSURED RETIREMENT INSTITUTE||$10,000|
|EQUIPMENT LEASING & FINANCE ASSOCIATION||$10,000|
|NATIONWIDE MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY||$9,000|
|NORTHWESTERN MUTUAL LIFE INSURANCE||$9,500|
|NATIONAL EDUCATION ASSOCIATION||$9,000|
|NATIONAL ROOFING CONTRACTORS||$9,000|
|AMERICAN MEDICAL ASSOCIATION||$9,000|
|COMCAST CORPORATION & NBC UNIVERSAL||$8,500|
|AMERICAN COUNCIL OF ENGINEERING COMPANIES||$8,500|
|AMERICAN ASSOCIATION FOR JUSTICE||$7,500|
|AMERICAN COLLEGE OF EMERGENCY PHYSICIANS||$7,500|
|AMERICAS HEALTH INSURANCE PLANS||$7,500|
|LIBERTY MUTUAL CO||$7,500|
|NATIONAL ASSOCIATION OF REAL ESTATE INVESTMENT TRUSTS||$7,500|
|FEDERAL EXPRESS / FEDEX||$7,500|
|AMERICAN SOCIETY OF ANESTHESIOLOGISTS||$7,500|
|OPERATING ENGINEERS LOCAL 139||$7,500|
|LABORERS INTERNATIONAL UNION OF NORTH AMERICA / LIUNA||$7,500|
|NATIONAL PORK PRODUCERS COUNCIL||$7,500|
|AMERICAN ACADEMY OF FAMILY PHYSICIANS||$7,500|
|AMERICAN ACADEMY OF NEUROLOGY PROFESSIONAL ASSOCIATION||$7,500|
|HEALTHCARE DISTRIBUTION ALLIANCE||$7,500|
|NATL TELECOMMUNICATIONS COOP ASSOC||$7,500|
|FIDELITY FMR LLC||$7,500|
|SHAKOPEE MDEWAKANTON SIOUX COMMUNITY||$7,050|
|AMERICAN VETERINARY MEDICAL ASSOCIATION||$7,000|
PEOPLE WHO GAVE KIND THE LEGAL MAX IN 2020
|CONTRIBUTOR||TOTAL||PLACE OF RESIDENCE|
|BEKENSTEIN, ANITA S||$5,600||Wayland, MA|
|BEKENSTEIN, JOSHUA (JOSH)||$5,600||Wayland, MA|
|CONROY, KEVIN T||$5,600||Madison, WI|
|DOANE, RUSSELL||$5,600||Menomonie, WI|
|FAULKNER, GORDON T||$5,600||Mount Horeb, WI|
|FAULKNER, JUDITH||$5,600||Mount Horeb, WI|
|FISHER, ROBERT J (BOB)||$5,600||San Francisco, CA|
|GRAY, JONATHAN D (JON)||$5,600||New York, NY|
|GRAY, MINDY D||$5,600||New York, NY|
|GRAYER, JONATHAN||$5,600||Harrison, NY|
|KLARMAN, SETH ANDREW||$5,600||Boston, MA|
|LAUX, JOSEPH||$5,600||La Crosse, WI|
|PARKER, ALEXANDRA LENAS||$5,600||Palo Alto, CA|
|PARKER, SEAN||$5,600||Palo Alto, CA|
|ROTH, HOWARD||$5,600||Wauzeka, WI|
|SCHNICK, ROSALIE A||$5,600||La Crosse, WI|
|SIMONS, NATHANIEL HENRY (NAT)||$5,600||Berkeley, CA|
|WANEK, RON||$5,600||Arcadia, WI|
TOP 100 DONORS TO VAN ORDEN IN 2020
|CONTRIBUTOR||TOTAL||TYPE||CITY OF RESIDENCE||STATE|
|VAN ORDEN FOR WI-03||$34,501||Non-Individual||BETHESDA||MD|
|CONGRESSIONAL MAJORITY CMTE||$10,000||Non-Individual||BAKERSFIELD||CA|
|SEAL PAC SUPPORTING ELECTING AMERICAN LEADERS||$10,000||Non-Individual||WASHINGTON||DC|
|SCHUH, KONYA D||$8,400||Individual||JANESVILLE||WI|
|EYE OF THE TIGER PAC||$7,500||Non-Individual||ARLINGTON||VA|
|SMITH JR, HAROLD BYRON||$5,600||Individual||PALM BEACH||FL|
|HILLMAN, TATNALL LEA||$5,600||Individual||ASPEN||CO|
|KRESS, DONALD F||$5,600||Individual||GREEN BAY||WI|
|DHEIN, JERE E||$5,600||Individual||GREEN BAY||WI|
|HENDRICKS, KIMBERLEE K (KIM)||$5,600||Individual||JANESVILLE||WI|
|NELSON, GRANT E||$5,600||Individual||PRESCOTT||WI|
|MICHELS, TIMOTHY J (TIM)||$5,600||Individual||HARTLAND||WI|
|MICHELS, BARBARA A||$5,600||Individual||HARTLAND||WI|
|UIHLEIN, RICHARD ELLIS (DICK)||$5,600||Individual||LAKE FOREST||IL|
|JOHNSON SR, MARK O||$5,600||Individual||RICE LAKE||WI|
|NELSON, CAROL J||$5,600||Individual||PRESCOTT||WI|
|WEBER, DONALD J (DON)||$5,600||Individual||LA CROSSE||WI|
|HARTUNG, DANIEL J||$5,600||Individual||MADISON||WI|
|MICHELS, PATRICK D||$5,600||Individual||BROWNSVILLE||WI|
|HENDRICKS, DIANE M||$5,600||Individual||AFTON||WI|
|TOLL, NANCY A||$5,600||Individual||FRANKLIN||WI|
|ZORE, DIANE||$5,600||Individual||RIVER HILLS||WI|
|PREGONT, JOSEPH T||$5,600||Individual||JANESVILLE||WI|
|MICHELS, MARYSUE C||$5,600||Individual||BROWNSVILLE||WI|
|LUDINGTON, PATRICIA A||$5,600||Individual||ONALASKA||WI|
|HILLMAN, ROBERTA W (BOBBIE)||$5,600||Individual||ASPEN||CO|
|SCHLOEMER, JAMES H||$5,600||Individual||MENOMONEE FALLS||WI|
|MACDONALD JR, WILLIAM F||$5,600||Individual||AMBLER||PA|
|WEEKLEY, RICHARD WELDON (DICK)||$5,600||Individual||HOUSTON||TX|
|WHITELOCK, VIRGINIA E||$5,600||Individual||SAN DIEGO||CA|
|UIHLEIN, ELIZABETH A (LIZ)||$5,600||Individual||LAKE FOREST||IL|
|BURKE, KATHRYN M||$5,600||Individual||FOX POINT||WI|
|MICHELS, KEVIN P||$5,600||Individual||FOND DU LAC||WI|
|MICHELS, CONNIE L||$5,600||Individual||FOND DU LAC||WI|
|MULLINS, LUKE||$5,600||Individual||JUNCTION CITY||WI|
|JOHNSON, BARBARA B||$5,600||Individual||RICE LAKE||WI|
|BOYCE, RICHARD W (DICK)||$5,600||Individual||WOODSIDE||CA|
|FOX, BRENT A||$5,600||Individual||JANESVILLE||WI|
|FRANKE, JAY||$5,600||Individual||MIAMI BEACH||FL|
|HERRO, DAVID||$5,600||Individual||MIAMI BEACH||FL|
|MLEJNEK, CHRIS||$5,600||Individual||RICE LAKE||WI|
|EVANS, CAROL A||$5,600||Individual||SAN DIEGO||CA|
|GELATT, PHILIP M||$5,600||Individual||LA CROSSE||WI|
|LETOURNEAU, EDWARD J||$5,600||Individual||DODGEVILLE||WI|
|WIESER, MARK A||$5,600||Individual||WISCONSIN DELLS||WI|
|IRVING, CRAIG||$5,600||Individual||SAN DIEGO||CA|
|HEIDT, GERALD||$5,600||Individual||SAN DIEGO||CA|
|SCHARLAU, CHRISTINA C||$5,600||Individual||ELK MOUND||WI|
|ARNOLD, SARA||$5,300||Individual||ELM GROVE||WI|
|NATIONAL REPUBLICAN CONGRESSIONAL CMTE||$5,000||Non-Individual||WASHINGTON||DC|
|MIKE HUCKABEE CAMPAIGN CMTE||$5,000||Non-Individual||LITTLE ROCK||AR|
|DICKMAN, CRAIG||$5,000||Individual||GREEN BAY||WI|
|BUSCH III, AUGUST ANHEUSER||$5,000||Individual||SAINT PETERS||MO|
|RICHARDSON JR, DR JOHN B||$5,000||Individual||VESTAVIA||AL|
|RICHARDSON, SONJA H||$5,000||Individual||VESTAVIA||AL|
|3RD DISTRICT REPUBLICAN PARTY OF WISCONSIN||$5,000||Non-Individual||LA CROSSE||WI|
|KOLBER, VINCENT A||$4,800||Individual||CHICAGO||IL|
|FETTIG, ROBERT P (BOB)||$4,800||Individual||LAKE GENEVA||WI|
|PEDERSON, TIMOTHY G (TIM)||$4,800||Individual||HARTLAND||WI|
|WISCONSIN REPUBLICAN PARTY||$4,500||Non-Individual||MADISON||WI|
|BLAINE LUETKEMEYER CAMPAIGN CMTE||$4,500||Non-Individual||ST ELIZABETH||MO|
|ELECTING MAJORITY MAKING EFFECTIVE REPUBLICANS||$4,500||Non-Individual||ANOKA||MN|
|KABARA, BETTY Z||$4,500||Individual||GALENA||IL|
|STEPHEN J (STEVE) SCALISE CAMPAIGN CMTE||$4,000||Non-Individual||NEW ORLEANS||LA|
|SORRELL, STEVEN A||$4,000||Individual||INDIANAPOLIS||IN|
|HANSEN, MICHAEL L||$3,800||Individual||FORT LAUDERDALE||FL|
|BECK, ELAINE E||$3,800||Individual||ORO VALLEY||AZ|
|SCOTT, JOHN D||$3,500||Individual||LAKE DELTON||WI|
|SCHARLAU, JOHN||$3,300||Individual||ELK MOUND||WI|
|HOLLFELDER, THOMAS A||$3,300||Individual||ELKHART LAKE||WI|
|AYLWARD, RICHARD J||$3,000||Individual||NEENAH||WI|
|RUSCH, JACK C||$3,000||Individual||ONALASKA||WI|
|MARTIN, JOSEPH C||$3,000||Individual||APPLETON||WI|
|CAMPBELL, ROBERT ROY||$3,000||Individual||LA CROSSE||WI|
|US ISRAEL PAC USI||$3,000||Non-Individual||HOLLYWOOD||FL|
|MILLER, DONALD K||$2,800||Individual||PALM BEACH||FL|
|ASNESS, CLIFF||$2,800||Individual||NEW YORK||NY|
|DAVID, JACK||$2,800||Individual||NEW HARTFORD||CT|
|HANNA, DAVID W||$2,800||Individual||IRVINE||CA|
|PEROT JR, H ROSS||$2,800||Individual||DALLAS||TX|
|HANNA, VIRGINIA L||$2,800||Individual||IRVINE||CA|